Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Stan's avatar

So we are to believe that bishops jumping up and down to irreverent music during mass, pagan rituals incorporated into the mass, open promotion of sinful lifestyles, kumbaya theology, polyanna "welcoming" and "inclusion", willy nilly edits of the catechism, transgender priesthood (girl altar boys, calls for priestesses by bishops and cardinals), irreverent handling of the eucharist, and blatant contradiction of most all teachings prior to the only pastoral council which is now the only dogmatic council are The Church? Sorry, this article doesn't begin to address the issue.

David McPike's avatar

'Religious liberty' is a phrase and as such certainly not a heresy against the faith, never mind 'predestination,' which is obviously a positive dogma of the faith. But then 'sedevacantism' is another word, and as such no more a heresy than the others.

And if the Catholic Church is empirically identifiable no less than FIFA or the AMA, even apart from faith(!), on the sole basis of the papacy, then the Catholic Church has no essential relation to the Catholic faith. And that's a big problem with Crean's view!

So maybe we better note that 'Catholic Church' and 'sedevacantism' are, like the other words, susceptible of multiple acceptations. So it's maybe not so clear what the 'indefectibility of the Church' actually means, nor what 'sedevacantism' means and what it implies about indefectibility.

Crean's main problem, seems to me, is that he wants to lean on a particular abstract contradiction, while ignoring the fact that sometimes there are contradictions both ways (it's a catch-22, Father!).

Regardless of Crean's one-sided appeal to contradiction, it remains a contestable (obviously) but empirical (for those with eyes to see) fact that the prelates of the Church have (if not 'formally' still *in fact*: in word and deed, in what they have done and what they have failed to do) defected en masse from the preaching of the gospel of Jesus Christ -- the *chief* corner stone, way more important than the pope! -- and from the traditional faith of the Church. (Long debate to ensue about the details of this; but regardless, Crean's neat little argument certainly does NOT settle it.) So why not think of the problem as one of how to formulate a non-heretical, non-contradictory-to-faith form of sedevacantism? That would be better than simply denying evident facts.

(The alternative is: If *that*'s the 'real' Catholic faith/Church, well then I never believed in it (and it seems neither did Jesus Christ, Paul, Peter, John, Matthew, Mark, Luke, Gregory, Augustine, Aquinas, etc.).)

42 more comments...

Ready for more?