Note: This article originally stated that eternal punishment is forgiven by baptism but not temporal punishments. In fact, all punishments whatsoever are remitted in baptism. The text has been corrected accordingly.—T&S
There has been a lot of talk on my side of the pond about the celebrity Russell Brand, who has been convicted of rape and sexual assault. As the darling of the left, he was a provocateur: he gained attention by saying outrageous things. However, two years ago he was baptised in the river Thames by his fellow-celebrity and friend Bear Grylls, and since about 2020 he has been building a new life for himself as a conspiracy theorist aligned with the political right.
The crimes for which he has now been convicted date to long before his conversion, but nevertheless Brand’s ideological evolution arouses suspicion among his many critics. We cannot, ultimately, know if his Christianity is sincere, or sincere to what degree, but was there a degree of convenience in his conversion?
Brand is not an isolated case. Milo Yiannopoulos, another British provocateur, reverted to the Catholicism of his childhood some years ago. He recently returned to his real home – the headlines – when he was deported from the USA back to Britain. Going back a few decades, the Conservative Party politician Jonathan Aitken, who went to prison for perjury, reinvented himself as an Anglican clergyman.
There are, of course, many less famous cases. One aspect of the phenomenon is simply that if you mess up in one social group you can try your luck with an opposing one. During the time when Catholics were persecuted in the 17th century, Titus Oates got material support and sympathy from Catholics by claiming to be one, and then got much more money and fame from Protestants by claiming to have seen the light, and to have vital information about Catholics’ nefarious activities. Former Catholics denouncing the ideas foisted on them as children, by their own account, have become as common as dandelions in anti-Catholic circles in Evangelical Protestantism, the Orthodox churches, and secular leftism. Convert Catholics who have made the reverse migration are also easy to find.
It is a mistake to imagine that just because a change of ideology or religion is convenient, that it is necessarily insincere. The prospect of making friends and even a living in a new milieu is not a good reason to accept the objective truth of its characteristic metaphysical claims, but it is an excellent reason for giving those claims a more careful look. The desire to fit in with a group of people who are potentially or actually sympathetic can have a powerful effect in dissolving long-held prejudices against them. Rational, non-rational, and self-interested factors can be mixed together in a complex way in even a high-minded person’s conversion. A less high-minded person can simply let himself go with the flow of warm feelings, if these look as though they are going to wash him onto sunnier shores. That doesn’t mean that his new beliefs are entirely fake or that he is play-acting: it just means that he is not very honest with himself. Then again, self-consciously cynical and insincere conversions are also very possible. God alone can judge us on such matters.




