Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Peter Kwasniewski's avatar

A friend of mine sent this comment privately and I'd like to share it here:

"I really believe that the lust for the new in the mid 20th century was fallout from the horrors of WW1 and WW2. The generation that came of age in the 1950s was taught to scorn everything that came before as somehow tainted and responsible for the horrors they heard about and saw. Modern art, architecture, medicine, science-- was sold to them and subsequent generations as superior and indicative of a more elevated, educated age. The Church was both an active participant and a proponent of this gigantic fallacy. Today the Church is disintegrating because of this."

Expand full comment
Anthony Buckley's avatar

Great series, Peter. Thank you. I have often wondered why the current pontiff, bishops and others have led such a concerted attack on the TLM and have sought vainly to eliminate it. I have come to the inescapable conclusion that at some point, like Martin Luther, Thomas Cranmer and other 16th century heretics, they could no longer bring themselves to believe in the Real Presence. For them, the Mass is just an empty ritual, a task to be completed. The TLM doesn't allow you to lapse into such heresy with its emphatic reminders of the most sacred truths of the faith concerning the Eucharist, especially in the prayers of the Offertory and the Roman Canon. The replacement of the beautiful Offertory prayers by a faux Jewish table prayer and the virtual elimination of the Roman Canon with artificially constructed replacements has sapped their faith in the fundamental beliefs of Holy Mother Church. Unfortunately they hold all the high ground in the Church and are prepared to exert their will in a tyrannical fashion.

Expand full comment
25 more comments...

No posts