It would once have caused no raising of eyebrows to state that Catholicism is inherently a religion of tradition. This was one of the main objections raised against it by Protestants, who, having settled on the doctrine of sola scriptura, discovered unsurprisingly that much of what the Catholic Church taught and practiced could not be found verbatim in the Bible. Yet this discovery should not have startled followers of the Apostle Paul, who wrote to the Corinthians: “I commend you because you remember me in everything and maintain the traditions even as I have delivered them to you” (1 Cor 11:2), and to the Thessalonians: “So then, brethren, stand firm and hold to the traditions which you were taught by us, either by word of mouth or by letter” (2 Thess 2:15).
The Church Fathers drove home this point with their customary vehemence. In his treatise On the Holy Spirit, published in 375, St. Basil the Great tells us:
Of the dogmas and messages preserved in the Church, some we possess from written teaching and others we receive from the tradition of the apostles, handed on to us in mystery. In respect to piety, both are of the same force. No one will contradict any of these—no one, at any rate, who is even moderately versed in matters ecclesiastical. Indeed, were we to try to reject unwritten customs as having no great authority, we would unwittingly injure the gospel in its vitals.
St. Basil helpfully tells us the sort of thing he has in mind, and if we listen carefully, we will hear some examples that may surprise us:
To take the first and most general example, who is there who has taught us in writing to sign with the sign of the cross those who have trusted in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ? What writing has taught us to turn to the East at the [Eucharistic] prayer? Which of the saints has left us in writing the words of the invocation at the displaying of the bread of the Eucharist and the cup of blessing? For we are not, as is well known, content with what the Apostle or the Gospel has recorded, but both in preface and conclusion we add other words as being of great importance to the validity of the ministry, and these we derive from unwritten teaching. Moreover we bless the water of baptism and the oil of the chrism, and besides this the catechumen who is being baptized. On what written authority do we do this? Is not our authority silent and mystical tradition? Nay, by what written word is the anointing of oil itself taught? And whence comes the custom of baptizing thrice? And as to the other customs of baptism, from what Scripture do we derive the renunciation of Satan and his angels? Does not this come from that unpublished and secret teaching which our fathers guarded in a silence out of the reach of curious meddling and inquisitive investigation? Well had they learnt the lesson that the awful dignity of the mysteries is best preserved by silence. What the uninitiated are not even allowed to look at was hardly likely to be publicly paraded about in written documents.
Another Church Father, St. Vincent of Lérins, around the year 434, had this to say in his great treatise Commonitory for the Antiquity and Universality of the Catholic Faith Against the Profane Novelties of All Heresies:
Keep the deposit. What is the deposit? That which has been entrusted to you, not that which you have yourself devised: a matter not of cleverness, but of learning; not of private adoption, but of public tradition; a matter brought to you, not put forth by you, wherein you are bound to be not an author but a keeper, not a teacher but a disciple, not a leader but a follower. Keep the deposit. Preserve the talent of Catholic Faith inviolate, unadulterate. That which has been entrusted to you, let it continue in your possession, let it be handed on by you. You have received gold; give gold in turn. Do not substitute one thing for another. Do not for gold impudently substitute lead or brass. Give real gold, not counterfeit.
Such quotations could be multiplied indefinitely.
The Church Fathers saw Christianity as a social and hierarchical religion in which certain men—the apostles and their successors—had been entrusted with dogmas, liturgical practices, and moral judgments that were intended to be passed on faithfully from one generation to the next. And this is a key point: the doctrine revealed by God, in its totality, was first deposited in tradition, that is, in the minds of the men whom God had chosen as His confidantes, and only subsequently was some of it placed in writing, at the discretion of the ones to whom the deposit had been given.



